Rebuilding retention on Klaviyo

Retention Marketing • Email & SMS • Direct Mail

Denny's

Denny's

Denny's

Overview

Denny’s ran email on Mailchimp and SMS on a separate platform. The two channels lived in different systems, with fragmented subscriber data, limited automation, and no single view of the customer. Roswell recommended that Denny’s consolidate everything onto Klaviyo, rebuild the automation program from the ground up, and add SMS, all without losing deliverability or revenue during the move.

Full Bleed Image

The execution

Klaviyo Migration


Migrated email from Mailchimp to Klaviyo in fall 2025 and moved from full-list sends to engaged-audience targeting, with a staged deliverability warm-up and suppression of long-unengaged contacts to protect sender reputation.


Automation Rebuild


Rebuilt the full automation suite in Klaviyo: welcome series, browse and cart abandonment, abandoned checkout, post-purchase, and customer win-back, plus seasonal camp-deposit flows.

SMS Launch


Launched SMS inside Klaviyo in April 2026 on a dedicated toll-free number, with its own welcome series, so email and SMS run off one profile and one set of data.


PostPilot


Added PostPilot direct mail for win-back, extending retention beyond the inbox.

The results

In its first seven months on Klaviyo (November 2025 through May 2026), email and SMS together drove approximately 28 percent of total store revenue, with email-attributed revenue growing nearly tenfold (9.7x) from the program's first full month on the platform to May.


Automated flows account for about a quarter of email-and-SMS revenue, led by cart abandonment at 25 percent of flow revenue, abandoned checkout at 16 percent, post-purchase at 14 percent, and the welcome series at 12 percent.


Denny's added roughly 13,800 net-new email subscribers since the migration, unique monthly email clickers grew more than tenfold from November to May, and returning customers account for about 76 percent of all orders — all while the store grew approximately 14 percent year over year.

9.7x

email revenue growth in the first month

Extending retention into direct mail

To reach customers the inbox misses, Roswell layered in PostPilot direct mail, starting with a lapsed-customer win-back program in May 2026. The signal is early but strong: the win-back program is already returning roughly 17× on spend and climbing, with the best-performing lapsed segment converting at 15% and returning more than 40×. As a brand-new channel, the program is still ramping, but it already extends the retention engine beyond email and SMS.


Underpinning all of it, returning customers account for about 76% of Denny’s orders, and the store grew about 14% year over year while the customer base expanded by roughly a quarter, giving the retention program a larger and growing audience to convert into repeat buyers.

Why it matters

Consolidating onto Klaviyo gave Denny’s one source of truth and a retention program that compounds month over month. In seven months it went from a migration project to roughly a quarter of store revenue, with SMS still early and seasonal flows continuing to ramp. One platform, two channels, and a growing share of revenue that Denny’s owns outright.