# From Search to Answers: Why Your eCommerce Brand Needs Answer Engine Optimization Now

Quick Answer: Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) is the evolution of SEO that optimizes content for AI-powered search experiences like Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and voice assistants. With AI Overviews affecting 30% of searches and causing up to 34.5% drops in traditional click-through rates, eCommerce brands must adapt immediately or risk invisibility in the new search landscape.

The $25 Billion Question: Is Your Brand Ready for the Post-Click Era? Picture this: A potential customer asks their phone, "What's the best sustainable fashion brand for work clothes?" In 2025, that query doesn't lead to your carefully optimized product page. Instead, an AI assembles an answer from across the web, potentially excluding your brand entirely, even if you rank #1 in traditional search. This isn't a future scenario. It's happening right now, 1.5 billion times per month. Here's what keeps us up at night at Roswell NYC: Yesterday, a client who's been crushing it in organic search for five years called us in a panic. Their traffic fell off a cliff—down 40% in two months. No penalties, no technical issues, perfect Core Web Vitals. The culprit? They're invisible in AI Overviews. This shift from traditional SEO to Answer Engine Optimization isn't just another algorithm update to ride out—it's a fundamental reimagining of how customers discover products online. And frankly, many agencies are still pretending it's 2019. So What Exactly Is Answer Engine Optimization? Look, we get it. Another acronym. Another "revolutionary" change that'll supposedly transform everything. But hear me out, this one's different. Traditional SEO is like getting your store listed in the Yellow Pages (remember those?). You want to be at the top when someone looks for your category. AEO? That's like having the smartest salesperson on your team jump into every relevant conversation about your products, wherever they happen. Slack, ChatGPT, voice assistants—anywhere your customers are asking questions. The difference matters because user behavior has done a complete 180. I'll spare you the "mobile-first" lecture (we all lived through that), but these numbers should make you sit up: Nearly 65% of Google searches now end without anyone clicking through to a website. AI Overviews show up in almost a third of US searches. Voice commerce (people literally talking to their devices to buy stuff) has exploded by 400% since 2021. And Gartner predicts that by 2026, a quarter of all organic search traffic will shift to these AI answer engines. For eCommerce brands, here's the kicker: AI Overviews love informational content (appearing 69.21% of the time) but barely show up for transactional searches (just 1.2%). That means the entire top-of-funnel discovery process is being rewritten, and most brands aren't even aware it's happening. The Hidden Crisis That's Already Hitting Your Bottom Line Last week, our head of Paid Media and SEO, Michael Rarick, dropped this bomb in our Monday meeting: "We're seeing traffic patterns that would've gotten me laughed out of the room in 2020." He wasn't exaggerating. When AI Overviews show up, here's what happens to your carefully crafted SEO: Top-ranking pages lose over a third of their clicks. Just gone. Poof. If you're unlucky enough to compete with both AI Overviews and featured snippets? Kiss 37% of your CTR goodbye. Non-branded keywords, you know, the ones that actually bring in new customers, are bleeding out with 20% declines. But here's where it gets truly bizarre. BrightEdge found that search impressions jumped 49% year-over-year, while click-through rates nosedived 30%. Translation: More people are searching than ever, but they're getting their answers without ever leaving Google. We've started calling this the "window shopping effect.” Everyone's browsing, but the AI bouncer won't let them into your store. And for eCommerce specifically, AI Overview appearances for shopping queries have cratered from 29% to just 4%. The AI doesn't want to recommend products—it wants to educate, which means you need a completely different strategy. The Roswell NYC Approach: Building for Both Humans and Machines Real talk: The first time we tried to explain AEO to a client, we sounded like we'd been hitting the tech conference Kool-Aid a bit too hard. "You need to optimize for an AI that doesn't exist yet!" But after countless late nights, too much cold brew, and more testing than any sane agency should do, we cracked the code. Here's the deal: You can't just write for Google anymore. You're writing for Google, ChatGPT, Alexa, and whatever Zuckerberg dreams up next week. Each has its own personality quirks (ChatGPT is weirdly obsessed with bullet points), but they all want the same thing—clear, direct answers they can serve up without a disclaimer. Making Friends with the Machines Think about how you'd explain your product to someone at a party. You wouldn't start with "Our company was founded in 1987..." You'd say something like: "We make sustainable work shirts that actually look good in the office. They're about $89, made from organic cotton, and you can get them in two days." That's AEO in a nutshell. Direct, conversational, and immediately useful. Building Your Brand's Digital DNA Google's Knowledge Graph is basically a massive web of connections between... well, everything. It knows that Nike makes shoes, that shoes are worn on feet, that feet are used for running, and so on. If your brand isn't in that web (or worse, if it's connected to the wrong things), you're invisible to AI. We work on what we call Entity Authority Building. Sounds fancy, but it's really about making sure AI systems understand not just what you sell, but why you matter. It's the difference between being "a company that sells shirts" and being "the sustainable fashion brand recommended by eco-conscious professionals." Speaking Human (Even to Robots) Voice search has completely changed the game. Nobody says "blue dress size 8" to their phone. They say, "Hey Siri, I need a navy blue cocktail dress for my sister's wedding next weekend. Something under $200 in a size 8." If your product descriptions still read like a spreadsheet, you're already losing. We help brands transform their entire catalog to match how real people actually talk and search. The Technical Stuff (That Actually Matters) Look, we could geek out about technical specifications all day, but here's what you actually need to know: Schema markup isn't optional anymore. It's like nutrition labels for AI—without it, they can't understand what you're selling. You need product schema with every detail imaginable, FAQ schema for all those customer questions, and organization schema so AI knows you're legit. Speed still matters—maybe more than ever. AI crawlers are impatient. If your site takes more than 2.5 seconds to load the important stuff, you're already losing. Mobile performance is even more critical since that's where voice searches happen. Structure your content like you're writing for a very smart fifth-grader. Clear headers, direct answers in the first paragraph, natural language throughout. If a human has to work to understand your point, an AI won't even try. Why You Need a Partner (And Yeah, We Think It Should Be Us) Here's the truth: The learning curve for AEO is brutal. What worked last month might be useless today. Google changes things, ChatGPT updates, and suddenly your entire strategy needs a rewrite. You could try to figure this out yourself. Plenty of brands are. They're also the ones panic-calling us three months later when their holiday traffic projections look like a ski slope. At Roswell NYC, eCommerce isn't just what we do—it's all we do. No B2B SaaS distractions. No local dentist websites. Just pure, unapologetic focus on helping brands sell products online. We've been Shopify Partners since before everyone AND your mom was on Shopify, and we've seen every trend, hack, and "game-changer" come and go. But here's what actually sets us apart: We're not just consultants who hand you a strategy deck and disappear. We embed ourselves in your team. Your wins are our wins. Your 3 a.m. emergencies become our 3 a.m. emergencies (but, actually, don’t call us at 3 a.m.). Our approach combines deep technical chops with an obsession for what actually drives revenue. Because let's be honest, visibility without sales is just expensive vanity. Your 90-Day Transformation Roadmap The clock's ticking, and every day you wait is a day your competitors get ahead. Here's how we typically approach an AEO transformation: Month One is all about assessment. We dig into your current visibility across AI platforms, see what your competitors are doing right (and wrong), identify the technical issues holding you back, and find the quick wins that can show immediate results. Month Two is when things get real. We implement schema markup across your key pages, restructure your content for AI comprehension, optimize for voice search on your bestsellers, and fix any performance issues that could hurt AI crawling. Month Three is about going big. We expand your visibility across all major AI platforms, integrate conversational commerce capabilities, build your entity authority in the Knowledge Graph, and set up tracking to measure what's working. The Bottom Line: Adapt or Disappear We'll level with you: We hate fear-mongering marketing as much as the next person. But this isn't crying wolf. The shift to AI-powered search is happening whether you've budgeted for it or not. Every week, we talk to brands that are hemorrhaging traffic and can't figure out why. Their traditional SEO game is tight—perfect technical setup, great content, solid backlinks. But they're ghosts in the AI-powered world. Their competitors? They're the ones showing up in every ChatGPT response and voice search result. Here's our challenge to you: Pull up your analytics right now. Compare your organic traffic from Q4 2023 to Q4 2024. If you're not seeing a dip yet, you're either incredibly lucky or you're already doing something right. Ready to Stop Playing Defense? The good news? You're reading this now, which puts you ahead of 90% of eCommerce brands who are still optimizing meta descriptions like it's 2015. We've helped brands navigate every major shift in digital marketing—from desktop to mobile, from organic reach to paid social, from email blasts to sophisticated automation. This AI revolution? It's the biggest one yet, but it's also the most exciting. Want to see exactly where you stand and what it'll take to dominate in the age of AI search? Let's talk. Book Your AEO Strategy Session → P.S. Seriously, the best time to start was six months ago. The second-best time is right now. Don't be the brand calling us in a panic next quarter.   About Roswell NYC We're a Webby Award-winning, full-service eCommerce agency based in New York City. As a Shopify Premier Partner, we've spent over a decade helping brands build, manage, and scale their online businesses. Our team specializes in creating intelligent digital experiences that actually drive revenue—not just traffic. We work with brands across Beauty, Fashion, Jewelry, Home, Luxury Goods, Wellness, and CPG, embedding ourselves as true partners in their growth.   Frequently Asked Questions About Answer Engine Optimization What exactly is Answer Engine Optimization (AEO)? It's the practice of making sure your content shows up in AI-powered search features—think Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT responses, and voice assistant answers. Unlike traditional SEO that focuses on ranking web pages, AEO ensures AI systems choose your information as the best answer. How is AEO different from traditional SEO? Traditional SEO is about getting clicks to your website. AEO is about becoming the answer itself. It requires more structured data, conversational content, and a deep understanding of how AI systems parse and prioritize information. Do I need to choose between SEO and AEO? Absolutely not. They work hand-in-hand. Think of AEO as SEO's younger, hipper sibling—it builds on the same foundation but adds new skills for the AI age. How quickly can I see results from AEO implementation? You'll typically see initial improvements in featured snippets within 30-60 days. Full AEO transformation usually shows significant results within 3-6 months. The key is starting now, before your competitors figure this out. Is AEO only important for informational content? For now, yes—AI favors informational queries. But here's the thing: optimizing your product info, FAQs, and category descriptions positions you perfectly for when AI commerce features expand. And trust us, they will.

## Contact Information
Address: 225 Broadway Suite 3100, New York, NY 10007
Phone: 212.227.6140
Email: contact@roswellstudios.com

## About Roswell
We are a full service eCommerce agency providing conversion focused experiences for direct-to-consumer (DTC) and B2B brands. Our portfolio grossed over $350M USD in 2024.