We are a full service eCommerce agency providing conversion focused experiences for direct-to-consumer (DTC) and B2B brands. Our portfolio grossed over $350M USD in 2024.

Full Service Ecommerce Agency

Roswell

mainNavigation

Work

Our work

About

About us

Insights

Design

Design & Creative

Technology

Growth

Growth Marketing

Core services

Technology Partners

Contact

More

Main Navigation Menu

Last updated: January 2026 | Reading time: 12 minutes

What Makes a Best in Class Shopify Store in 2026? {#what-makes-best-in-class}

In 2026, Shopify stores aren’t just competing on design or price. They’re competing on 

discoverability, efficiency, and adaptability

AI-driven discovery is reshaping how shoppers find products. Agentic commerce is changing how purchases happen. And paid media is more expensive than ever, which means conversion efficiency matters more than volume.

The brands winning right now aren’t chasing shiny features. They’re building Shopify stores that convert consistently, scale cleanly, and evolve as commerce continues to fragment.

This is what “best in class” actually looks like in 2026—plus the benchmarks to aim for and real-world patterns we see from high-performing Shopify brands.

First, let’s define “best in class”

Loads fast enough that users don’t bounce

Merchandises products like a human, not a database

Builds retention into the experience by default

Is structured so AI, search, and modern discovery tools can clearly understand it

it makes buying easy, obvious, and repeatable.

The benchmarks that separate “fine” from “best in class”

Before tactics, you need targets. These aren’t universal truths—every category, price point, and traffic mix is different—but they give you a clear sense of whether your store is 

If you miss these, everything else becomes harder and more expensive.

If your product detail pages or collection pages fail Core Web Vitals, you’re paying for traffic you can’t fully convert.

Commerce benchmarks (directional, not gospel)

Instead of chasing industry averages, best-in-class brands focus on 

That said, performance typically shakes out like this:

Many Shopify stores hover around ~2%. Strong performers push past that, and best-in-class brands often land in the 3–5%+ range depending on category, price point, and traffic quality.

Roughly 70% is still considered “normal” across ecommerce. Best-in-class stores don’t eliminate abandonment entirely—but they consistently outperform their category average by removing friction and uncertainty.

Mobile conversion almost always trails desktop. Best-in-class stores actively work to close that gap through simplified navigation, clearer merchandising, and cleaner PDP layouts.

steady, measurable improvement in the places that actually drive revenue

The 8 traits of best-in-class Shopify stores in 2026

1. They’re fast where it matters (not just the homepage)

Optimize images per template, not globally

Speed isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s a conversion lever.

2. Mobile is the primary experience—not the afterthought

Most Shopify traffic is mobile. Many stores still design for desktop first.

Surface shipping, returns, and trust cues without endless scrolling

If mobile search usage is high but mobile conversion is low, your navigation or collections are the problem—not your traffic.

3. Product pages answer questions immediately

Your PDP should replace a sales associate.

Show real social proof (photos, specifics, context)

Remove uncertainty around shipping and returns

If customers are emailing support with basic questions, your PDP isn’t doing its job.

4. Collections are merchandised, not dumped

“Here are 180 products” is not a strategy.

Default to intent-driven sorting (often Best Sellers wins)

Include merchandising moments like bundles, starter kits, or gifts

Collections should guide decisions, not overwhelm them.

5. Checkout is frictionless—and boring (on purpose)

Accelerated payments (Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay)

Every extra step, field, or surprise costs you money.

6. Personalization feels helpful, not creepy

In 2026, personalization isn’t about novelty. It’s about speed to confidence.

Smart cross-sells that actually make sense

Quizzes only when complexity justifies them

The goal is to help customers decide faster—not impress them.

Fulfillment, inventory accuracy, and operational readiness 

8. The store is built for AI and modern discovery

Use clean product titles and descriptions

Structure content so it can be summarized, quoted, and recommended

If an AI assistant can’t confidently explain your product, you’re already behind.

What we look for when auditing Shopify stores

When we audit a Shopify store, we’re not looking for perfection. We’re looking for 

These are the signals that tell us whether a store is built to scale—or quietly leaking revenue.

1. Where performance breaks down by template

Best in Class Shopify Store 2026: Benchmarks, Examples & Conversion Optimization Guide

Welcome to "The Orbit," where e-commerce movers and makers share the real stories behind their brands. In this episode, host Nihar Kulkarni (Roswell NYC) talks with one of the most talented and insightful minds at Shopify, Senior Solutions Engineer Michelle Drawert.

Michelle shares her fascinating and unconventional path into e-commerce, her deep-rooted passion for supply chain, and her expert take on how AI is set to augment—not eliminate—the human side of retail.

A Foundation in Retail (Before E-Commerce Existed)

Long before she was a solutions engineer, Michelle began her career in tech. But her very first job out of college was at a major fast-fashion retailer. This was before e-commerce was mainstream; the company had a "dot com, a splash page" but sold its products at 600 mall-based locations across the US.

Working in corporate, Michelle was a distributor, responsible for "planning assortment". She would manually select how many units of each SKU went to which store , basing her decisions on sales figures, trends, geography, and even weather.

"I looked at green and white striped paper... we used pencils," she laughs. While she jokes that this job probably doesn't exist anymore , the experience gave her a deep, fundamental understanding of retail, inventory, and sell-through —a passion that would define her future career.

The "McDonald's" Lesson: Why Supply Chain is Everything

When Michelle officially pivoted to e-commerce, one of her first managers taught her a lesson she never forgot. He asked his new team, "What's the first step in placing your order at McDonald's?".

The team guessed walking up to the counter or looking at the menu. The manager kept pushing them to think earlier. The real answer? "The purchase of the grain that was planted in the field... that eventually turned into the flour that made the bun".

"That's the first step," he explained, "because without the bread, there wouldn't be a hamburger on the menu". This lesson ignited Michelle's passion for supply chain , a topic she believes is a fascinating and critical entry point for anyone new to the industry.

Shopify's AI Directive: Augmentation, Not Elimination

As a Senior Solutions Engineer, Michelle works with partners like Roswell to solve complex merchant requirements using Shopify's platform. A huge part of that platform is now AI.

"AI is a directive" at Shopify, she explains. The company's vision is to have AI "represented in as many surfaces of the product as possible". This started with Magic and has evolved into powerful tools like 

, which leverages "network intelligence".

This tool allows a merchant to target high-intent buyers by tapping into the collective, anonymized data of the entire Shopify network. For example, a tennis apparel brand can serve ads to an audience of customers who have purchased tennis balls from 

 participating Shopify store in the last six months. "You share, I share, we all benefit," she says.

But Michelle is quick to point out that AI's true value is 

. The goal isn't to lay off staff ; it's to "reallocate" human talent. Why have brilliant, creative people doing tedious, manual tasks when AI can handle them? The real benefit is freeing up your team to focus on "things that are meant for growth versus just keeping the lights on".

On "Vibe Coding" and the Future of the Front-End

Host Nihar Kulkarni notes that agencies like Roswell are now focused on "building for our brains, not for our hands," acting as "executive producers" for an AI-driven output.

Michelle agrees, emphasizing that she still believes in the "beauty of the human oversight". She appreciates AI for sourcing insights and code, but she doesn't "know how I feel about AI having an opinion that is based on an emotion". The human element—the creative inception—remains irreplaceable.

Michelle describes working at Shopify as "fascinating". Her first impression was that "everyone that I've met... is just really smart". The company is built on a massive engineering team and is intensely focused on "craft development" , allowing people to become true masters of their lane.

The most exciting part is the velocity. "What other commerce platform do you know of that has that many releases at this velocity of a cadence?" she asks, referring to the hundreds of updates that drop with every bi-annual Editions. This speed, combined with a thoughtful, future-proof strategy , is what allows entrepreneurs to start on Shopify for $5 a month and grow into a global, omnichannel enterprise on the very same platform.

From Merchandising to Machine Learning: How Shopify Shapes the Next Era of Retail

2025 Webby People’s Voice Award for Best Website and Mobile Site in the Shopping & Retail category

—the official online store of fashion icon 

This honor is especially meaningful because it was 

, making it a true reflection of how customers are engaging with the digital experiences we design.

A New Era for DVF—Powered by Shopify, Designed by Roswell

When DVF partnered with Roswell NYC, the goal was clear: bring a legendary fashion brand into the digital age with a site that could tell a story, sell seamlessly, and scale with purpose.

, leveraging the platform’s powerful commerce infrastructure while delivering an immersive, editorial experience that feels authentically DVF. Every detail—from mobile responsiveness to conversion flow—was crafted to reflect the brand’s timeless style while performing at the highest level.

 is decided entirely by the public. That makes this win a powerful signal: 

It proves that performance and brand storytelling don’t need to be separate goals—they can work together beautifully.

“Winning the People’s Voice Webby for DVF.com is especially rewarding because it came directly from the public,” said 

, Managing Director of Roswell NYC. “DVF represents timeless style, and we’re proud to have built a platform that honors that legacy while delivering real business results.”

 (a designation held by only the top 6.8% of agencies), Roswell NYC brings together full-service capabilities—from UX strategy and design to development and retention marketing.

Our work on DVF.com is a perfect example of what happens when:

UX and conversion strategy go hand-in-hand

Technology is used to amplify—not dilute—a brand’s legacy

We build businesses

Webby - Winning eCommerce: DVF & Roswell NYC

A New Era for DVF—Powered by Shopify, Designed by Roswell

Why the People’s Voice Webby Matters

Our Approach: Style Meets Strategy